Loyalty 2.0: how to supplement traditional bonus programs
Restaurant loyalty strategies in 2025: supplementing points with personal attention and guest challenges. Includes Starbucks reward changes and questions for a program audit.

Loading audio…
—:—
Consider a hypothetical regular who collects loyalty points for two years, then stops visiting. The food and service are still good, but waiting to earn 50 points for a free coffee no longer feels worthwhile. A reward alone does not guarantee that a guest will stay with a restaurant.

Traditional bonus programs offer benefits through points, visit-based discounts, and VIP cards. They do not replace the experience of eating at your restaurant. Loyalty 2.0 here refers to ways to supplement a bonus program.
The authors of Brand Loyalty and Generations X, Y, Z report that Gen Z is less brand-loyal than earlier generations. When evaluating your program, account for Gen Z’s expectations: value during the current visit may appeal more than a reward that takes months to earn.
Why points do not guarantee loyalty
Owners sometimes equate having a loyalty program with guests feeling attached to a restaurant, although these are different things. A guest may redeem rewards simply because they are a good deal. If another restaurant offers a better deal, accumulated points may not be enough to keep that guest.
Young guests distinguish between a transactional relationship and genuine value. They may not value discounts for their own sake: they want a worthwhile experience during the current visit or genuine attention from staff. A restaurant that offers no reason to return risks losing that guest to a place where they find the experience and emotional connection they want.
Many restaurants advertise “personalized offers,” but these usually amount to grouping people into “coffee lovers” and “dessert fans,” with discounts for each group. This is basic segmentation: it ignores individual habits. Picture a barista who remembers a guest’s cinnamon cappuccino with no sugar and starts making it before the order. Or a server who knows the guest avoids spicy food and warns them about a dish’s spice level. A host might remember that a guest celebrated an anniversary last month and ask how it went.
Starbucks: changing rewards and customer trust

In 2023, Starbucks drastically devalued rewards in one of the world’s most successful loyalty programs, which it had built over decades. The rules changed unilaterally: a reward that had cost 150 stars began to cost 200. A favorite drink that had been free became available only with an extra payment.
Paul Barron, host of the Restaurant Masterminds podcast, explained why he stopped visiting: “This was the key reason I stopped going to Starbucks. If you can’t afford a loyalty program—don’t run one at all.”
A guest who had spent years collecting stars and planning purchases around rewards could feel cheated and undervalued: the company had devalued the rewards they were counting on.
Before launching a program, assess whether you can sustain the promised rewards. If you are not ready to invest in guest relationships long-term and see the program only as an expense, do not launch it. Be honest with guests instead of promising rewards you will later have to reduce or cancel.
Personal attention and clear terms
Loyalty develops through human interaction, when guests feel valued as people rather than as a source of revenue. An entry in a CRM or points database does not create that relationship by itself. Picture an employee smiling at a guest and writing their name on a takeout bag. In this example, the smile and the name on the bag take 10 seconds. That gesture helps build an emotional connection that rewards alone cannot replace.
Compare two possible memories for a guest: earning 500 points and receiving a complimentary dish after a server notices their bad mood. A host calling the next day to ask whether the guest enjoyed the visit is another example of attention. Personal care can leave a stronger memory than financial value.
For a Gen Z guest, insincerity in an interaction can quickly cause disappointment, while genuine care may encourage them to recommend a restaurant and become a brand ambassador. An inspiring experience may justify paying more. Consider the public response, too: guests may post about a good visit on social media or describe a disappointing one in a critical review.
Guests find information about program terms within a few clicks and scrutinize company decisions. Do not count on keeping rule changes, reward cuts, or fees hidden: a guest who discovers them may stop visiting and share criticism on social media, damaging the restaurant’s reputation. Disclose the terms fully: announce changes in advance and explain the reasons. If financial difficulties mean you cannot maintain the previous rewards, say so openly. Do not count on guests forgiving deception.
Gamification as an alternative to waiting for rewards

Short challenges with a deadline offer an alternative to collecting points for months. A restaurant could devise an “Olympic Challenge”: visit five times during the Olympics to earn an exclusive prize. The reward would be an experience money can’t buy; it would not be a discount or free meal.
Brands have run time-limited campaigns around cultural events such as Eurovision, offering prizes for visits rather than relying solely on conventional rewards.
A challenge can meet the need for achievement: completing it makes a guest feel like a winner. An exclusive prize can add a sense of uniqueness, and joining a shared event can create a sense of belonging. Guests may post their progress, tag the restaurant, and invite friends.
Possible challenges include:
- Try every dish on the fall menu within a month.
- Bring 3 new friends and earn an exclusive culinary masterclass.
- Take the best photo of a dish and win a private lunch with the chef.
How to review your loyalty program
Learn how to optimize your restaurant’s operations
Audit the current program
Before changing anything, assess where you stand. Most restaurants do not know the real numbers for their loyalty programs. Collect data on how guests use yours:
- How many members actively use it, rather than simply registering?
- On average, how long does it take to redeem a first reward after registration?
- How many members use it regularly, at least once a month?
- What is the program’s return on investment?
- Is members’ average order value increasing, and how does it compare with that of other customers?
Add surveys, focus groups, and conversations with regulars to the numbers. Ask what they like, what annoys them or feels inconvenient, and what would encourage them to use the program more often. Find out how they heard about it and whether they would recommend it to friends.
Account for individual guest preferences

Use the Eatery Club™ loyalty program to build relationships with guests. The program itself should not be your ultimate goal.
- Read order history to understand preferences, rather than push dishes.
- Instead of a template birthday SMS, include a discount on a favorite dish in an automatic birthday greeting.
- Explain recommendations: a guest who enjoys spicy Asian food might be interested in new Thai noodles.
Instead of formal Bronze, Silver, and Gold tiers, consider statuses based on guest habits. “Favorite Guests” visit regularly and receive something special; “Explorers” try new dishes; “Sociables” often bring friends and contribute to the atmosphere.
Connect digital channels with service
Your QR menu and website can go beyond a digital catalog to suggest food and drink pairings, display unobtrusive promotions, and collect real-time feedback on dishes.
A mobile app can be a channel for spontaneous, pleasant surprises. Possible scenarios include:
- A personal push notification instead of a general promotion broadcast: “Hi Alex! It’s a great day for our summer salad. Want to try it?”
- Access to new dishes exclusively for active users.
- Booking a favorite table.

Where to start
Start with a program audit and guest feedback. Train staff to build emotional connections with guests: notice their preferences and give them personal attention. Reassess your tools as technology changes: they should support service, not replace relationships. When evaluating the program, consider the quality of guest relationships alongside visit frequency.
Published in



